Comments for Comcast Joins NY's Anti-Newsgroup Crowd, Shuts Off Access

Comcast Joins NY's Anti-Newsgroup Crowd, Shuts Off Access

2008-09-19T18:31:29Z

Comcast has joined pretty much every other ISP in New York by shutting off access to newsgroups, effective two days ago, although current users will still have access through October 25th. A lot of stories on this topic have focused on how New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo has led the overall "crackdown" due to kiddie porn, but we think this is really just a politically convenient business decision to cut costs on a service that's declining in popularity. DSLReports seems to agree, and they offer some advice on where you can get affordable newsgroup access now that your ISP is no longer footing the bill.

Bill, who sent us the tip, writes,

Note that to replace this service, a person would have to buy at least a $7.99 per month service from a Usenet provider. But Comcast is not going to lower the price of their Internet service to compensate customers for the loss of Usenet access.

(Photo: Getty)

Comment from Anonymous on 2008-10-28

2008-10-28T20:00:24Z

Here is a list of specials offered by premium Usenet providers to Comcast customers and others affected by ISP's cutting newsgroup access:

[http://www.newsgroupreviews.com/isp-newsgroup-specials.html]

Comment from Ajh on 2008-09-20

2008-09-20T21:16:24Z

@boones farmer: If you want to go for clueless broadband reps I called verizon to ask about their dsl. The rep didn't know what bandwidth was.

Comment from t325 on 2008-09-19

2008-09-20T04:17:24Z

@johnarlington: In Soviet Russia, newsgroup block you!

Sorry, it had to be done.

Comment from BearTack on 2008-09-19

2008-09-20T01:36:26Z

Andrew Cuomo is the barbarian who ran a sword through Archimedes. An abuser who uses children as both sword and shield to achieve political ambitions, and without thought for the damage done.

Comment from orlo on 2008-09-19

2008-09-20T00:48:22Z

If Cuomo was serious he'd encourage Usenet access and track down those who upload child porn. Oh, and maybe follow the chain until he finds those producing it. Driving things more underground is good for the kiddie porn business because prices will go up.

Comment from ncboxer on 2008-09-19

2008-09-20T00:23:39Z

usenetserver.com- 13.33 a month/unlimited. Maxes out my cable connection every time.

Comment from StevieQ on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T23:29:45Z

I've been using Giganews for many years, and the service and cost is excellent.

Comment from Ashcan on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T23:23:47Z

Comcast provided all their customers with a Giganews "Bronze" monthly package for free, which normally sells for $7.99 a month direct from Giganews. But I bet Comcast is not going to lower my bill $7.99 a month for the loss of the service.

Comment from MarvinMar on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T23:18:10Z

www.usenetserver.com

MONTHLY PLAN
10 Connections / SSL Included
105+ Days Retention
$14.95 per month

my plan
UNS HI-SPEED PLUS
20 Connections / SSL Included
105+ Days Retention
$17.95 per month

Sign-up here [www.usenetserver.com]

Comment from Pixelantes Anonymous on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T21:30:54Z

Google Groups has allowed free Usenet access for everything except the binaries groups ever since they bought Deja.com.

Comment from Clold on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T21:28:46Z

Not only did Verizon turn off alt.* access, they raised my FiOS $96 a year

Comment from Parapraxis on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T21:22:36Z

@axiomatic:

easynews. global search makes it awesome.

Comment from kc2idf on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T21:17:12Z

It's really the shrink ray, now isn't it?

Comment from Trai_Dep on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T21:07:42Z

It seems if BitTorrent is such a "problem", they'd want to keep alternatives to BT available. If, y'know, they were a service industry.

Comment from maxx22 on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T21:03:29Z

Time Warner did this a few months ago. One day's notice. Not a word here (although I sent it in).

Comment from axiomatic on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T20:52:18Z

@elislider: agreed Easynews is just as good as Giganews.

You fail at failing Comcast.

Comment from elislider on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T20:41:32Z

giganews ftw

Comment from lannister80 on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T20:22:59Z

www.newshosting.com. $15/month for unlimited downloads.

Comment from johnarlington on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T19:59:42Z

While I was in Russia, our ISP flat out blocked all newsgroup access, oh yeah and just about everything else. It was sweet

Comment from Brazell on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T19:59:17Z

I use Newshosting.com ... it's pretty great + Newzbin, split with my roommate like $4/month.

Comment from winstonthorne on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T19:56:03Z

If this happened to a DSL customer, could they, in theory, argue that it's a "material difference" and get out of their contract early? If so, that'd be pretty sweet. (I'm not a DSL man myself, but I know a lot of people are stuck in 3-year contracts).

Comment from FLConsumer on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T19:55:56Z

I don't get the outrage? I get all of the kitty porn I want from [www.ratemykitten.com] .

Comment from WinnipegDragon on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T19:50:48Z

Premium server - $10/mo
NewsBinPro (or your choice of robot) - $60
binsearch.info - Free

Any show/movie/software you could imagine? Priceless.

UseNet will never die.

Comment from nybiker on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T19:49:53Z

Verizon is only sticking with the Big 8 of news groups as noted in this announcement on their website:
"On 06/24/2008, Verizon will be modifying its Newsgroup offerings to only offer groups in the Big-8 Newsgroup hierarchies, which are listed below. Users will not be able to post or download from any other newsgroups.

comp.*
humanities.*
misc.*
news.*
rec.*
sci.*
soc.*
talk.*

More information on the Big 8 hierarchies is available at www.big-8.org.

The 0.verizon.* newsgroup hierarchy will also continue to be available."

I guess part of the loaf is better than no loaf.

Comment from Laffy Daffy on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T19:38:32Z

Comcast had a problem a few months ago and the link to Giganews was severed. I called Comcast support and spoke to three people at there who had no idea what I was talking about -- never heard of Usenet, never heard of newsgroups, flatly denied Comcast had any such service. Incredible.

Comment from Goatweed on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T19:22:06Z

why is there no outrage over the cable companies not lowering their rates, considering they are providing less of a service now?

Comment from Watcher95 on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T18:57:14Z

Then again, ISP provided newsgroup access is normally pretty lame compaired to a premium newsserver. Much higher completion and retention rates.

I switched to a pay service years ago and never looked back.

Comment from ElizabethD on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T18:57:06Z

It is totally worth 10 Euros per year to me to subscribe online to the "German news server". It carries a zillion newsgroups and is reliable. I've been a subscriber for years.

[news.individual.net]

Comment from nicemarmot617 on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T18:54:26Z

@humphrmi: I'm not surprised to hear RCN would pull such a thing. They were throttling my BitTorrent two years ago, way before I ever even heard of such a thing. It wasn't until I moved and switched to Time Warner that I realized what had been happening. And if they'll do that you know that they couldn't care less about any newsgroups. After all, people complain about them in those newsgroups!

Comment from Ben_Q2 on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T18:53:42Z

Its funny back in the 90s I used to bring in the groups to S. Ca. It was full of porn sure, but its how I was able to put a master set of guy hebert cards together. It was always something the ISP had to pay for, and what most people did not know is really why. All newsgroup severs have or has to hold all the newsgroups. Can anyone say Many TBs per day?

alt, bin, etc would come in so fast that it would lock up the hard drives. We used to have to reboot the servers every hour.

Comment from humphrmi on 2008-09-19

2008-09-19T18:39:54Z

RCN also turned off their news servers, this Monday, without notice. After some complaints on DSLReports, they apparently turned them back on later in the week. I don't expect them to stay on very long - with the push from AGs I'm sure the ISPs are chomping at the bit to dump this expense.

Sigh. I miss comp.misc.